Opening Statement on Right to Counsel Bill


PROPOSED INT. 214-2014

SEPTEMBER 26, 2016



The incredible turnout here is a testament to the seriousness of the issue we are addressing today.  We are here to address a crisis. That crisis is the threat of eviction faced by tens of thousands of tenants, our fellow New Yorkers, who are on an incredibly uneven playing field in a place where the standard should be fairness.

But there is no fairness in an eviction proceeding when the landlord has an attorney and the tenant does not.  And that sadly is precisely the situation faced by the vast majority of tenants today.

The results of this injustice are predictable: an epidemic of evictions - 22,000 last year alone.

The good news is we know how to bring that painfully high number down.

We know that when you provide a lawyer to a tenant their chances of avoiding eviction improve dramatically.

Anyone who doubts this only has to look at the numbers.  Over the past two years, thanks to an incredible commitment from both the mayor and the City Council we have dramatically increased our funding for anti-eviction legal services.

And this has resulted in a 24% drop in the numbers of evictions compared to two years ago.

This is an astounding result and one we should all be proud of.

But let’s not spend too much time patting ourselves on the back.  Because even today 73% of low-income tenants are still facing eviction proceedings without an attorney.

Our bill, intro 214 would change that. It would give every low-income tenant the right to an attorney.  And that will be a game change here in New York City, that will reverberate across the nation.

The moral case alone is enough for us to pass this bill.  But i hope this hearing today will also focus on the financial case.

Because establishing a right to counsel is an investment that will save our city millions of dollars every year.

The math is not that complicated.  It costs around $2,500 to provide a tenant a lawyer.  But if that same tenant were to have no lawyer, and would be evicted, and--as happens in so many cases when families are evicted--were to wind up homeless, it would cost the city tens of thousands of dollars:

  • in shelter costs

  • In extra services in schools

  • In extra emergency room visits

  • In increased applications for unemployment benefits

  • In increased mental health services

And since over half of evictions are in rent-regulated units, and we all know those units often go market-rate once vacant, when we invest in lawyers to prevent evictions we also save thousands of affordable apartments, which otherwise the city would have to spend millions of dollars to replace.

But don’t take my word for it.  Look at what the experts say.

The New York City Bar Association commissioned a report by the respected financial analytics firm Stout Risius Ross which concluded that intro 214 would ultimately save New York City no less than $320 million each year.

So for moral and financial reasons I urge my colleagues to support this bill.

Sign up for our mailing list!

Report a Problem Participatory Budgeting Events

Mark In Action

Mayor Bill de Blasio and City Council members on Friday afternoon announced an agreement on the city's $92.8 billion budget for fiscal 2020, with initiatives to improve health care access at its forefront. The budget includes $26 million to place 200 additional social workers—including 85 working within the city's mental health initiative, ThriveNYC—in public...

Under legislation drafted by the City Council, the de Blasio administration would have to report on its efforts to notify school staff and the students who attended dozens of public schools during the 2001-02 school year that were not far from the World Trade Center site about programs available for...

The city is trying to have tenants sign new leases that only list one official occupant. By Noah Manskar, Patch Staff NEW YORK — New York City is forcing tenants of beleaguered buildings that it owns to sign new leases — and the conditions have raised hackles among lawyers and lawmakers....

By Brian M. Rosenthal The New York attorney general’s office said Monday it had opened an inquiry into more than a decade of lending practices that left thousands of immigrant taxi drivers in crushing debt, while Mayor Bill de Blasio ordered a separate investigation into the brokers who helped arrange...

City Councilmember Mark Levine has announced the 2019 winners of participatory budgeting in his district, which includes parts of the Upper West Side, Morningside Heights and Washington Heights. The projects to receive funding are: $250,000 for air conditioning upgrades and new water fountains at P.S. 165 Robert E. Simon School...

By Sabrina Mallot Last fall, the City Council introduced a package of 18 bills aimed at preventing tenants from being displaced due to aggressive tactics from landlords like exploitative buyout agreements or nuisance construction. On Wednesday, May 8, all but one passed. They still require the mayor’s signature, but he...

By Eddie Small The hallways of Bronx Housing Court are crowded and chaotic on a typical weekday morning. Lawyers and tenants scurry across the white tile floors and lounge on the worn-down benches of the Grand Concourse building, where occasionally the sound of one person shouting out a name will...

By Elizabeth Kim A collaboration between a group of housing rights advocates has produced the most comprehensive database yet to measure evictions across New York City and identify many of the landlords responsible for them. Three advocacy groups — Right to Counsel NYC Coalition,, and the Anti-Eviction Mapping Project —...